Disruptive Behavior Caught on Tape: Time to Finally Stop Misbehaving Docs

Ilene MacDonald

Medical journalist Ilene MacDonald

One year ago this week, we were forwarded the following article, written by medical reporter Ilene MacDonald in FierceHealthcare. We felt strongly enough by what she had to say that we responded.

The article:

You may have missed a story in FierceHealthcare this week about a lawsuit involving an anesthesiologist’s shocking behavior in the operating room.

Shocking because the tirade, which was accidentally caught on tape, featured an outrageous and, frankly disgusting, exchange between Tiffany Ingham, MD, and her surgical team, in which she called the unconscious patient a “retard” and a “wimp” and also speculated that he was gay due to his alma mater, the University of Mary Washington, a former women’s college. 

The patient, an unnamed Virginia man, didn’t intend to record the conversation. He had hoped to capture the doctor’s post-discharge instruction via a cellphone recording, but accidentally taped the entire examination because his clothing was put under the operating table. Imagine his surprise when he fully awoke from his stupor to hear the physician and surgical team he entrusted would care for him, instead insult him, express a desire to punch him in the face, and deliberately misdiagnose him.

The incident is appalling on so many levels, but the idea that a provider would falsify medical reports and the patient safety risks that are inherent in this kind of disruptive and distracted behavior, are especially so. 

The jury was also offended by the unprofessional behavior. Their verdict: Ingham (who no longer works at the Aisthesis anesthesia practice in Bethesda, Maryland and has since moved to Florida, according to the Washington Post) must pay her former patient $500,000 for defamation, medical malpractice and punitive damages.

One of the jurors told the Post that Ingham didn’t have much of a defense because the entire conversation was on tape. Although there was some disagreement among the panel as to how much the patient should be awarded, the jury finally decided “that we have to give him something, just to make sure that this doesn’t happen again.”

I’d like to think that the public slap on the wrist and the payout would be enough to stop disruptive behavior among doctors. But the fact is, the industry has long put up with this trash talk and bullying behavior. A December 2014 study in JAMA found that of 523 physician leaders and 321 staff physicians, 71% witnessed disruptive behavior in the previous month and 26% were disruptive at one time in their career.

“Why does the industry put up with it? Last year FierceHealthcare reported that many hospitals don’t do anything about the problem because troublesome physicians often generate a lot of revenue.”

But Michael A. Carome, M.D., director of health research at the nonprofit consumer rights advocacy group Public Citizen, in the District of Columbia, told Syracuse.com at the time of that report that the bad behavior is a patient safety risk. “When we allow bad physicians to remain in practice, that can ultimately expose hundreds if not thousands of patients to substandard and unprofessional care,” he said.

It’s time hospitals finally adopt a zero-tolerance policy for bad behavior–and let’s hope the $500,000 judgment (small money really) amidst a consumer-driven movement in healthcare will finally be the wake-up call the industry needs.


Our response:

Please tell us you’re kidding. “Wake-up call?”

We happen to investigate physician misbehavior for a living. That’s why we hold just under 16,000 names in our files over a mere 12-year time span – a sobering number of whom are documented by the NPDB as “Dangerous or Questionable.” A large percentage of those in prison for Murder or Rape, Kidnapping, Drug running, Bank robbing, outrageous Healthcare Fraud, Prescription Scams and filming their nude patients, were already ‘disruptive physicians’ who – like punky 8th graders – were allowed to graduate to greater fun & games. And they did.

Garbage behavior doesn’t spawn itself overnight.

How serious is health care in weeding out their own 3% lunatic fringe? In our view: not very. Not, for example, as long as they are willing to actually relicense physicians who kill their wives. Who could be surprised they might simultaneously continue to tacitly approve throwing sharp objects; filming their staff in the bathrooms and groping nurses?

Do some homework: the typical MD arrested for anything, has been acting like a chimp on chocolate for years.

The ugly reality is, our healthcare juggernaut exhibits an appalling indifference to the swathe of carnage it carves through society. It is far, far too impressed with it’s own successes, to fret over its foibles. Try looking at it this way for just 30 seconds:

American medicine will (almost assuredly) kill 2,000,000 citizens by the year 2035.

Now, you may want to go back and ogle all those zeros.

How excited do you expect them to get, really, over the little things – like insulting unconscious patients (as the unnamed patient in this case) or snapping selfies with an unconscious, nearing-death celebrity? (as evidently happened in the Joan Rivers case)

You’ll forgive our lack of ability to conjure up a convincing shocked-face.

We do thank you for the article.




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s